Hernia Repair Techniques: A Comparison

Feature Herniotomy Hernioplasty (Mesh Repair) Herniorrhaphy (Suture Repair)
Description The most basic procedure, involving only the identification and excision of the hernia sac. No muscle repair is performed. The modern standard for adults. The hernia defect is reinforced with a synthetic mesh, which acts as a scaffold for new tissue growth. A traditional technique where the surgeon stitches the patient's own muscle tissue together to close the hernia defect.
Common Use Almost exclusively for paediatric patients with congenital indirect inguinal hernias. The go-to for most adult hernias: inguinal, femoral, incisional, umbilical, and ventral. Considered the gold standard. Used for small hernias (<2cm) in patients with strong tissue, or when mesh is contraindicated (e.g., infection).
Indications
  • Symptomatic inguinal hernias in infants and children.
  • Prevention of incarceration or strangulation in paediatric patients.
  • Most primary and recurrent hernias in adults.
  • Large hernias where a suture repair would be under high tension.
  • To achieve the lowest rate of hernia recurrence.
  • Small hernias with strong surrounding fascia.
  • Contaminated or strangulated cases where synthetic mesh is unsafe.
  • Patient preference or when mesh is unavailable.
Contraindications
  • Not suitable for adults due to acquired muscle weakness.
  • General contraindications to surgery (e.g., severe illness).
  • Active infection or contamination at the surgical site.
  • Strangulated hernia with bowel contamination (relative contraindication).
  • Known allergy to mesh materials (rare).
  • Large hernias (high tension leads to high recurrence).
  • Recurrent hernias where tissue is already scarred and weak.
  • Patients with known connective tissue disorders.